"Bloodline Recollector: Apparently I’m Reading a Different Card."
by:
Virgilio F. De leon Jr. MD
Most of the time, I just listen to MTG influencers.
I find many of them amusing, and I don't really get into arguments with them on X or Twitter, or jump into comment wars, because they each have their own way of presenting cards and their own particular takes on the game.
That's part of what makes Magic content fun.
But every once in a while, I'll hear something that makes me stop and think:
“Wait… what?”
It baffles me when an influencer calls a card “mediocre” and then compares it to another card as if the comparison completely settles the argument.
I'm never quite sure whether they're deliberately rage-baiting players into reacting or whether they genuinely believe that the card is mediocre.
Case in point:
Bloodline Recollector.
Apparently, some people are disappointed that this is one of the headliners of Reality Fracture.
Some have even compared it to what people are calling its Multiverse counterpart, Emeritus of Ideation.
And apparently, some influencers believe the five-mana Emeritus of Ideation is simply the better card.
I'm sorry.
Did we read the same Bloodline Recollector?
Because if you haven't looked closely at what this card actually does, let me walk through one particularly ridiculous possibility.
You can literally cast Dark Ritual, use the mana to cast Bloodline Recollector, and because it is already prepared, you can immediately use the Ancestral Cravings attached to it.
On Turn One.
You draw three cards.
You lose three life.
And you can do it to a target player.
At instant speed.
So I'm sitting here wondering:
How exactly is Emeritus of Ideation better?
For one thing, Bloodline Recollector can fit into a whole range of Vampire decks.
And in colors that have some of the best ways of killing creatures in the game, getting three creatures to die in a turn doesn't exactly sound impossible.
Once that happens, Bloodline Recollector can be prepared again.
And then you get to do it again.
And again.
And again.
Sure, Emeritus of Ideation doesn't make you lose life.
I'll give you that.
But I don't think the life loss is necessarily a drawback when we're talking about Ancestral Cravings.
Because Bloodline Recollector doesn't just let you draw three cards.
You can also make an opponent draw three cards and lose three life at instant speed.
And suddenly, the life loss becomes part of the weapon.
Especially in a deck that is already good at whittling down an opponent's life total, three cards and three life could potentially be the last nail in the coffin.
It also reminds me of an older era of Magic, when cards like Ancient Craving and Sign in Blood could actually become lethal because drawing those cards wasn't necessarily a gift.
Sometimes the last three cards you draw are the last three points of life you're going to lose.
And that is what I think people are overlooking with Bloodline Recollector.
They're looking at it as another card-drawing creature.
I'm looking at it and thinking:
“How many ways can I abuse this?”
That's a very different question.
So, yes, I honestly don't know what that particular influencer was thinking that day.
Maybe it was rage bait.
Maybe they weren't in the mood to make content.
Maybe they simply evaluated the card differently.
And that's perfectly fine.
Magic is a game where reasonable people can look at the same card and reach completely different conclusions.
But on this one, I have to politely disagree.
Bloodline Recollector deserves to be a headliner.
Even if Reality Fracture has a whole lot more going on.
And if someone wants to call this card mediocre, that's fine.
I'll just be over here casting Dark Ritual on Turn One.
Draw three.










_cover_art.jpeg)